Blog:.'Bizarre situation'
So why has the music industry fallen in love with deluxe versions of albums?
The recent trend dates back to last year's special edition of Amy Winehouse's Back To Black, which contained live songs and her cover of The Zutons' Valerie.
"You had the bizarre situation of the limited edition charting at one position and the other version charting at another," the Entertainment Retailers Association's Kim Bailey says.
Record labels cottoned onto the wheeze and chart rules were relaxed in September, allowing deluxe and original versions of an album to count towards the same chart position.
Rihanna's Good Girl Gone Bad deluxe edition, which came out in June, also attracts the ire of Yahoo!'s Masterton.
Released more than a year after the original, which sold more than a million copies, the Reloaded edition had new artwork and three new tracks.
"Rather than getting her to record a new album, they just tacked tracks onto the back of the old album and re-released it," he says.
Universal UK's commercial director, Brian Rose, says: "If an artist brings incredible new content to us, we reserve the right to put it out and give the consumer more choice."
But he adds: "We will always aim to release the deluxe edition date on date with the standard edition."



